Robinson Meyer, “Why Saying ‘Climate Crisis’ Falls Flat.”
As summarized on social media by Luis Lopez:
The interviews did two things at once, they confirmed that the three segments have genuinely different communication needs, and they also revealed how much those needs nonetheless overlap:
Taking the differences first, Skeptics generally responded relatively well to an economic and freedom-based case for clean energy that never mentioned climate…
Persuadables asked for hard proof of claims about clean energy affordability, including concrete and local evidence that it works and lowers bills, and they warmed to clean energy presented as an opportunity rather than a sacrifice…
Persuadeds, already convinced, evinced a need for direction instead, a specific and achievable set of things they could do. Messaging built for any one of these audiences could easily fall flat with another, or even push it away.
Still, the overlap mattered just as much, with several patterns that held across all or nearly all of the 15 conversations…
One such pattern was that the language of crisis and catastrophe fell flat everywhere, though for different reasons in each segment —while Skeptics dismissed such descriptions as manipulation, Persuadables experienced them as exaggeration that clashed with the gradual changes they observe in their own lives and, even Persuadeds who consider climate change an urgent threat, described apocalyptic framing as more numbing than motivating, presumably the opposite of the intended effect…