A Free-Market Energy Blog

Unstoppable Change, Stasis, and Climatism

By Charles Battig -- April 24, 2018

“Thousands of years of climate adaptation by untold numbers of biological species is now viewed by climate alarmists as an obsolete process, as they assume that the global climate environment has reached its ultimate optimum state of ‘now’.” 

The most recent rebuttal by Rob Bradley to a “Climate Alarmist at R Street” included reference to “change” as a primal fear among the environmental alarmists. Stasis, indeed, is a defining characteristic of the Malthusian, deep ecology worldview held by many natural scientists working in academia.

Inherent in our earthly existence is change. Change characterizes all physical entities on some time scale. Order succumbs to disorder, unless work is expended to mitigate it, at least according to the law of entropy. Yet climate is held to a pseudo-spiritual standard of enduring timelessness and unchanging behavior.

Change, indeed, is also central to business and economic concepts. The second most famous term in economics (after the “invisible hand”) is creative destruction, where the better replaces the good because of shifting consumer demand and wholly new entrepreneurial offerings. Business is about shifting on a dime as profit/loss signals dictate–or be left behind.

Eco-Stasism

A present Panglossian perfection is assumed by the eco-radicals to exist for the climate. Human life spans are a short blip on the geological time line, and so the current Gaia worshipers have been spared the hardships of their ancestors when  they had to deal with the realities of the last Ice-Age. One wishes that human flourishing in the Age of Fossil Fuels was their standard instead.

The following essay of mine, “The Only Thing We Have To Fear Is Change Itself,” was published in 2014 (with a few changes here).  It explores this theme, and attempts to relate this change angst to current social mores.

Climate change is heralded as a most pressing challenge and potential danger to mankind.  Many politicians have responded to an outpouring of writings by scientists eager to supply evidence for such claims. Such scientists are coincidentally eager to maintain governmental funding, and their jobs.  Our Federal government imposes arbitrary environmental regulations, based on selective interpretations of tortured data.  As a result, the public now suffers from politicized climate change angst.

Command-and-control politicians seized climate change as a new opportunity to be seen responding favorably to the concerns of their constituents. In implementing governmental policies claiming to alleviate the claimed climate change, they affirm H. L. Menken’s oft cited dictum that: “The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by menacing it with an endless series of hobgoblins, all of them imaginary.”

This surely is an age-old example of a feedback loop, albeit this time in the political, sociological realm. First instill a fear, then provide research papers to validate the fear, which will in turn magnify the original fear. Forget the nuances of climate sensitivity, the mathematical sign, + or -, of cloud feedbacks, solar influences, and geological and astronomical cycles.

For the public at large, a worrisome scare story will oft outdo the best efforts at logical refutation. Consider how much greater is the effort to calm a panicked theater audience once someone has falsely cried out “fire,” as the frightened mob rushes for the doors. Logical argument is trampled underfoot.  The news media live by the “If it bleeds, it leads” mantra.

Amongst the imaginative list of climate induced impacts claimed are those detrimental to both our physical and mental health. In the spirit of post-normal science, also known as “abby-normal science, I offer an explanation for the public’s fear of climate change…one based on our current cultural mores.

The Hollywood self-adulation and eternal youth culture is supported by a plastic surgery industry, cosmetics, and pharmaceuticals…both traditional and herbal.  Life-prolonged mental clarity and youthful dexterity are goals of Zen yoga. The public has become mesmerized by images of (nearly) non-aging stars, and wants the same for itself.  They might be termed the “Botox® generation.”

No wrinkles, no sags with the passage of time, no physical changes as one chronologically ages.  Indeed, the natural desire to preserve and improve one’s own image, and the ability for some to achieve it is a blessing of our time. However, biological change has not been repudiated, but rather esthetically repackaged. 

Public expectation is that one is able to “non-age” in the fulfillment of philosopher/mathematician Leibnitz’s proposition that “we live in the best of all possible worlds.” This best is now; no change needed; change is bad; change is “abby-normal.” Unlike the ability of a deft plastic surgeon to erase the unwanted evidence of the passage of time, there exists no corresponding means to thwart climate change.

Juxtaposition of the two only moderately worrisome words “climate” and “change” has produced the killer app “climate change.” Of the two, change is the more emotionally charged word. The current cultural notion that traditional biological change can be altered at will is at the heart of the receptiveness of the public to concern over manmade climate change. 

Undesired change is experienced as bad for us as individuals, and bad for all species. If biological non-aging can be a human goal, why should the physical world not be changeless? Why must we endure climate change?  If it does change, we must assume it is of human doing, and can be reversed by human intervention. King Canute had his lesson in humility at the seashore, but that is forgotten history for the current eco-generation.

Thousands of years of climate adaptation by untold numbers of biological species is now viewed by climate alarmists as an obsolete process, as they assume that the global climate environment has reached its ultimate optimum state of “now.” 

Changes to this optimized “now” environment are viewed as insurmountable challenges of survival rather than a normal part of the fabric of biological adaptation.  No matter where on earth one is living, that environment is now held to the new standard of “no change.” Species extinction has become viewed as a manmade crime against mother Gaia.

Weather patterns are now to remain confined to a stable narrow range of not too hot, not too cold. Not too many nor too unusual tornadoes, hurricanes, nor sea level rise lest there be a hint of change.

For the “Botoxed generation,” the thing they fear is change itself. Try to change that.

6 Comments


  1. Ed Reid  

    The climate change “resistance” is effectively a crusade to restore Camelot.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8h7E5rtnFH4

    Of course, not even Camelot matched the description, no less the rest of the globe.

    Reply

  2. Harold Doiron  

    Charles,

    Thanks for this witty and thought-provoking expose’ of irrational thinking.

    Reply

  3. Richard McFarland  

    A beautiful reminder that evolution accompanies geologic change and that we are currently in a period where fossil fuel permits evolution to a next period where undoubtedly nuclear fusion and even fission will propel us to an even more utopian period where we’ll evolve energy sources beyond our current imaginations. If the worst that the earth is capable of challenging us with along the way is a few degrees of temperature variation, then so be it. Get serious. We are the race that anticipates overcoming the challenge of living on Mars!

    Reply

    • tomwys  

      Not only Mars, but Venus too! About a thousand small machines parachuted to its surface will strip Carbon from its atmosphere and release the O2, leaving a pile of Carbon black and a diamond or two. The increasing O2 will make then atmosphere transparent. Heat release can then plunge temperatures – I think you can figure out the rest!!!

      Reply

  4. Energy & Environmental Newsletter: May 14, 2018 - Master Resource  

    […] Unstoppable Change, Stasis, and Climatism […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply